L.A.’s Mass Transit Delusions Are Getting More Delusional

The agency’s motto ought to be “build it, and no one will come”

At one point, allegedly serious people though this was a realistic idea. Computer rendering of the since scrapped Sepulveda Pass monorail concept.

The fact that they’re even considering this proposal reflects how divorced from reality L.A. Metro’s board of directors collectively are. During a fractious meeting in Sherman Oaks on Monday, officials presented a plan to convert the parking lot at the Westfield Fashion Square Mall into a train maintenance facility.

The punchline? The train to be maintained does not yet exist, and possibly never will.

For years, transit types in L.A. have salivated over the idea of a commuter rail line through the Sepulveda Pass. At one point they proposed a monorail. Somewhere, Phil Hartman was laughing as one of his most famous Simpsons bits came to life. The current plan calls for a 12.5 mile underground heavy rail subway. The estimated cost is $25 billion. Of course, everyone knows that, should it ever actually get built, it will cost several times that much. For that, Angelenos would get seven stations, connecting Santa Monica to Panorama City.

For perspective, the entire 400 mile California High Speed Rail project was originally pitched to voters as a $33 billion project. Current estimates put the price tag at $126 billion, with high end estimates as high as $231 billion. Applying the low end of those multiples – 3.8x, which is not unusual for these kinds of projects in California – to the Sepulveda Pass proposal could round out to nearly $100 billion. For example, the Metro Purple Line subway extension was originally forecast to cost $2.8 billion. The finally tally will be nearly $10 billion, 3.6x more.

The plan also would spell the end of the mall, an economic anchor in that part of L.A. Metro would seize the parking lot through eminent domain. This reflects another aspect of the transit cabal’s delusions, that transit is equal to or better than driving. There are a few places in the country where that’s true, notably Manhattan. Like it or not, L.A. is a car-centric city, and it always will be. Taking away a shopping mall’s parking lot is taking away its customers. It will wither on the vine and die, taking its jobs and tax base with it.

Metro’s delusion is such that a possible alternative location for the maintenance facility is south of the mall and would require the demolition of multiple existing businesses in an area where residents have been working with the LA City Planning Department to develop mixed-use multi-family housing, including affordable housing and significant open spaces. That’s right: they’re considering destroying a local business community and building an industrial site where neighbors are calling for housing and open space. You can’t make this stuff up.

All this to support a train that virtually no one will ever use. Yes, commuting over the Sepulveda Pass is miserable at commute times. It devours hours out of commuters’ lives every week. The only worse option is transit.

The realities of mass transit in L.A.

For the vast majority of trips and the vast majority of commuters, mass transit in L.A. simply doesn’t make sense. Consider a trip from a random location in Panorama City – I picked 8446 Cantaloupe Ave. – to UCLA. In the middle of the day, that is, when traffic on the pass is flowing freely, the trip takes about 35 minutes by car and more than 90 minutes via transit, assuming no delays and you catch the required transfer without waiting. At peak commute times the trip by car can take up to 90 minutes, and the same for transit. Again accounting for transfers and first/last mile travel, assume the proposed subway shaves 30 minutes off the transit option. On its face, there’s appeal to that option, whisking underground through the pass as commuters grumble behind the wheel above you. There’s a catch, though. You’re still at the mercy of L.A.’s mass transit system. You’re riding a bus to the subway station and a bus to your final destination. Depending on how far away those bus stops are from your point of origin and final destination, there’s some walking involved. Transit’s advantage evaporates altogether if you add another stop or two.

Meanwhile, the world is on the cusp of the next great transportation revolution. We’re a decade away from a new generation of quiet, hyper efficient supersonic jet travel. Autonomous air taxis will be a reality as soon as the 2028 Olympic Games in L.A. On the ground, autonomous taxis have become routine. Nearly 100% of 2026 model year cars offer some form of driver assistance such as automatic following, automatic emergency braking, lane tracking and adaptive cruise control. Nearly a third offer next gen technology like automatic steering. Those numbers increase every year. And while fully self-driving cars are a ways off, they are a matter not of if, but when.

I was in a brand new Tesla ride share a couple of weeks ago. The driver described how he wasn’t even operating the pedals. The car was doing it for him. It was a perfectly smooth ride. This increasingly will be reality. There’s discussion to be had about the consequences of human beings slowly losing the ability to operate a car. Then again, I don’t know how to ride a horse or operate a steam engine. Most people under the age of 40 don’t know how to drive a stick shift.

The (shockingly near) future. AI rendering of an air taxi over L.A.

In the face of this exciting, even inspiring near future, Metro is offering 19th century transportation technologies in the form of trains and bicycles. And they don’t care how many neighborhoods they have to disrupt and how many local business communities they have to destroy to bring about their Utopia. We’ve seen this movie many times in L.A. over the last two decades. Light rail lines consistently have failed to deliver on their promise to alleviate traffic. Bicycle lanes and road diets have hurt local business districts. Infamously, some two dozen businesses closed on the road dieted stretch of Venice Boulevard within two years of that much-maligned road diet. Much of Downtown L.A. is barely navigable by car these days. I was downtown for a Lakers game two nights ago and was staggered by how much road space has been taken away from drivers.

A good theory, hijacked

It’s good public policy to offer Angelenos alternatives to driving. It’s not so good to pursue an ideological agenda that amounts to a simplistic “cars bad, everything else good,” and to effectively punish people for getting around via the mode that makes the most sense. As usual, lower income and working Angelenos bear the brunt. It’s the thoroughfare in their neighborhood that gets ripped up to make way for a new light rail line. While collar professionals can make money sitting in traffic by taking calls, giving dictation or even just cogitating. The landscaper in his pickup in the next lane, burning extra gasoline while trying to get to a client? Not so much.

L.A.’s decades long, multibillion dollar experiment with public transit has failed. Metro boasts of robust numbers, but as the saying goes there are lies, damned lies and statistics. The agency claimed 27.3 million boardings in June of this year. The key word is “boardings.” Not “passengers” or “riders,” but “boardings.”

Assuming most riders make two-way trips, we can cut that number in half to 13.7. A substantial majority of trips require at least one transfer, so we can halve the number again, to 6.8 million. Finally, if we assume that a substantial number of riders are daily users, dividing 6.8 million by 20 work days gives us about 350,000 monthly passengers, or just over 3.6% of the county’s population. Add back a few occasional riders, we can bump the number to half a million. That’s smack in the middle of the U.S. Census Bureau’s estimate of 3.7% to 6.8%.

L.A. needs a transportation reset

There are better ways forward. First, L.A.’s political class needs to drop their antipathy to the cars upon which around 83% of the city’s and county’s population rely. Second, they need to scrap their obsession with big, shiny, multibillion dollar projects like the Sepulveda subway. Third, join the 21st century. Explore partnerships with autonomous ride hailing services. Consider AI powered shared jitney services that transport multiple people from point to point. Embrace the coming era of “vertical transportation” like air taxis. Fourth, invest in larger projects only where ridership demand – actual human beings, not fanciful numbers plucked off the taxpayer Christmas tree – justify them.

Finally, start working with neighborhoods and communities, not on them. Practice a bit of humility before telling a neighborhood like Sherman Oaks what you’ve already decided to do, like it or not. Democracy, and public services like mass transit, work best from the ground up, not the top down.

Transit has a place in Los Angeles, but not as a centerpiece of the region’s mobility and economy. More people would use it if, rather than cramming multibillion dollar pipe dreams into every corner, Metro planners started with actual demand. According to a study by the UCLA Institute of Transportation Studies, 9% of Metro’s lines carry 83% of passengers. That’s a woefully inefficient system that’s ripe for an overhaul. Imagine if the agency spent $25 billion on a diversified, world class system that actually responded to rider needs and demands. To paraphrase Jake Barnes said at the end of The Sun Also Rises, wouldn’t it be pretty to think so?

2 thoughts on “L.A.’s Mass Transit Delusions Are Getting More Delusional”

  1. This problem dates back to the corrupt Garcetti administration and it admirable that you carry on the battle by use of facts

  2. Let’s not forget the mess road diets have caused in the otherwise charming downtown part of Culver City. It’s craziness. The bus lanes are always empty. Driving a car is taxing because you’re never sure what lane you’re allowed to be in. It’s fair to say that downtown Culver City is the new Santa Monica, an excellent place to visit and have fun. That needs to be nurtured, or Culver City will become what downtown Santa Monica has become, a dystopian disappointment.

Leave a Reply